Minimizing Time Card Fraud: Strategies for Retail Companies

July 20, 2023

by Malysa O’Connor

Minimizing Time Theft Blog Thumbnail

Time card fraud, a form of time theft, poses a significant risk to businesses’ financial stability and operational efficiency. This deceptive practice involves employees misrepresenting their work hours on their timesheets or machine-stamped time cards, leading to exaggerated work hours and unnecessary payroll expenses.

In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the intricacies of time card fraud, exploring its various forms as well as strategies that your C-suite and HR team can implement to prevent such occurrences.

In summary, you can prevent time theft by:

  • Using Time and Attendance Systems
  • Optimizing Schedules
  • Setting Clear Break and Lunch Policies
  • Performance Tracking
  • Leveraging Automation and Technology
  • Encouraging Employee Engagement and Motivation

Time Card Fraud: The Art of Stealing Time

Employees who commit time card fraud dishonestly manipulate their working hours to receive compensation for time not worked.

The Many Faces of Time Card Fraud

There are several ways employees commit timesheet fraud, including:

  • Buddy Punching: When an employee clocks in or out for a coworker who isn’t present at work. Buddy punching is a prevalent form of time theft that affects 75% of businesses in the United States, according to the American Payroll Association (APA).
  • Inflated Hours: When employees exaggerate the hours they worked on their timesheets.
  • Ghost Employees: When payroll records include individuals who don’t work for the company, often created by dishonest managers or HR personnel.

The Cost of Time Card Fraud

Time card fraud can hurt a company’s bottom line by increasing labor costs without corresponding productivity gains. It also creates an unfair workload distribution among staff members and fosters a culture of dishonesty that can erode team morale and trust. Businesses are also exposed to potential legal issues related to wage and hour law violations.

Preventing Time Card Fraud

The best way to minimize time card fraud is by implementing a modern workforce management software such as Legion WFM. These solutions provide advanced tools such as automated time-tracking systems with geofencing capabilities, schedule optimization features, break policy enforcement mechanisms, and performance-tracking modules—designed to deter fraudulent behaviors while enhancing overall operational efficiency.

A comprehensive approach to preventing time card fraud should also focus on fostering a positive work environment where employees feel valued and motivated. Engaged employees are less likely to engage in behaviors that result in lost time.

Don’t let time card fraud steal your company’s time and money. Act now to keep time clock fraud from draining your organization’s resources.


Key Takeaway
Time card fraud is when employees cheat their employers by falsifying their working hours to get paid for time they didn’t actually work. This can be done through various methods such as buddy punching, inflated hours, and ghost employees. It can hurt a company’s bottom line and create an unfair workload distribution among staff members, exposing businesses to potential legal issues related to wage and hour law violations.

Preventing time card fraud requires implementing intelligently automated workforce management solutions like Legion WFM. These systems provide advanced tools designed to deter fraudulent behaviors while enhancing overall operational efficiency.

Time and Attendance Systems

Robust time and attendance systems accurately track employee hours, reducing opportunities for timesheet fraud.

  • Clock-in Parameters: These rules are the first line of defense. They record the exact number of hours worked and prevent early or late clock-ins that could lead to inflated paychecks. You can set up rules that are automatically enforced for how long before/after a shift an employee can clock in. These parameters ensure that workers adhere strictly to their schedules, minimizing lost productivity due to early departures or late arrivals.
  • Geofencing: Geofencing technology ensures employees can only clock in when they’re physically present at the workplace. Restricting where an employee can log their hours significantly reduces the chances of time theft.

Automation and Technology

In today’s digital age, automation and technology are key players in preventing timesheet fraud. Modern workforce management software that enables intelligent automation, like Legion WFM, can significantly reduce the chances of fraudulent activities.

WFM that’s intelligent and automated eliminates manual, error prone processes to ensure f work hours are accurately tracked without any room for discrepancies.

  • Digital Time Clocks: These devices require personal identification methods such as PIN codes, swipe cards, or biometric data (like fingerprints), making it nearly impossible for employees to commit fraud.
  • Sophisticated Software: Advanced workforce management systems not only track attendance but also monitor productivity levels. They provide comprehensive reports detailing each employee’s working hours, breaks taken, tasks completed, etc., offering valuable insights into potential areas of concern or opportunities for improvement.
  • Mobile Applications: Many employee mobile apps allow employees to clock in, clock out, and track time from their smartphones. This limits the opportunity for time clock fraud that involves other employees. Smart geo-fencing parameters ensure that employees can only clock in when they are within designated work locations.

Besides mitigating time theft risks, automation offers numerous other benefits, including improved efficiency, reduced administrative workload, and a better experience for hourly employees. It allows HR managers more time to focus on strategic tasks rather than getting bogged down with tedious paperwork related to attendance tracking or payroll processing.

To sum up: embracing modern technology is no longer optional—it’s a necessity if you want your business operations to run smoothly while safeguarding against time fraud.

Schedule Optimization

Optimizing your schedules can help maximize labor efficiency. Advanced workforce management software allows you to optimize schedules automatically, aligning employee availability with business demands while minimizing lost time.

The Benefits of Schedule Optimization

  • Avoid under-staffing or over-staffing situations that waste time and productivity.
  • Ensure employees are scheduled for shifts they can actually work, reducing late arrivals and early departures.
  • Discourage “buddy punching” by providing visibility into who is working when and where.

Schedule optimization improves operational efficiency and employee satisfaction. Fair, predictable schedules that align with personal preferences boost morale, motivation, and engagement.

Features of a Good Workforce Management System

A good system should offer automatic schedule generation based on predefined rules, real-time updates to accommodate last-minute changes, and integration with attendance systems for seamless tracking and reporting.

Break and Lunch Policies

Creating comprehensive break and lunch policies that outline when breaks should be taken, how long they should last, and what activities are permitted during these periods, are key to preventing timesheet fraud.

  • Automated Alerts: Use your workforce management software to set up automated alerts reminding managers when it’s time for their scheduled breaks or lunches. This ensures adherence and maintains productivity levels.
  • Schedule Adherence Reports: Regularly review schedule adherence reports generated by your system. Identify patterns such as chronic late returns from break times or extended lunch hours.
  • Prompt Action: Address any discrepancies promptly with the concerned employee(s). Consistent monitoring coupled with swift action sends a strong message about company expectations regarding compliance with break/lunch policies.

Enforcing strict break and lunch policies can also minimize costly penalties associated with non-compliance with labor laws about mandated rest periods. The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) requires employers in certain industries to provide specific rest periods during work shifts—failing which could result in hefty fines.

An effective strategy around managing break times goes beyond just preventing potential timesheet fraud; it also plays a crucial role in maintaining legal compliance while fostering an environment of fairness at work.

Employee Engagement and Motivation

Engaged employees are generally more productive, committed, and loyal. They take ownership of their work and are less likely to commit time fraud. Regular communication, feedback sessions, team-building activities, and opportunities for professional development can help foster employee engagement.

Acknowledging Outstanding Performance

Recognizing hard work goes a long way toward building trust and loyalty. Regularly rewarding top performers with incentives like bonuses or promotions, encourages them to maintain high productivity standards while discouraging dishonest practices such as time theft.

Selecting a WFM provider that includes performance and rewards modules and an engaging workplace culture can significantly reduce instances of time card fraud while boosting overall productivity levels within the organization.

Performance Tracking

Keep an eye on employee performance to catch and prevent time clock fraud. Address issues quickly and offer training to improve productivity.

Why Regular Monitoring is Important

Regular performance monitoring ensures employees stick to their schedules. It helps you spot patterns that may suggest time theft.

Evaluating Employee Performance Accurately

Accurate evaluation involves more than just checking clock-in and clock-out times. Use tools like our retail workforce management software to track productivity metrics.

Take Prompt Action on Issues

Don’t delay action if you notice consistent tardiness or early departures. Addressing these issues immediately sends a clear message about your company’s stance against time fraud.

Offer Corrective Measures & Training Opportunities

  • Corrective Measures: Consider disciplinary actions for repeat offenders or changes in scheduling if lateness is due to personal circumstances.
  • Training Opportunities: Conduct workshops on time management skills if lack of understanding seems to be the issue.

Maintaining high standards for punctuality helps foster a culture of respect for colleagues’ time and company resources, making it less likely for anyone to engage in time card fraud.


Time card fraud is no joke—it can cost companies significantly and hurt employee morale.

But fear not; there are ways to combat this issue: use time and attendance systems, optimize schedules, enforce break and lunch policies, track performance, leverage automation and technology, and promote employee engagement and motivation.

It’s no coincidence that all of this can be done through our AI-powered WFM system. If you want to prevent timesheet fraud, schedule a demo with our team today. We’ll help you achieve that and so much more.