If you’re mid-evaluation on a workforce management platform, one question tends to dominate the business case: what’s the actual return? A new Total Economic Impact™ study from Forrester Consulting, commissioned by Legion, quantifies the potential return. Forrester found that a composite organization using Legion Workforce Management realized $50.8 million in three-year, risk-adjusted present value benefits against $3.5 million in costs—a net present value of $47.3 million, a 13x return on investment, and payback in under six months.
The headline is compelling on its own, but for procurement, finance, and operations teams building their own case, the methodology behind it matters just as much. Forrester interviewed four decision-makers with experience using Legion, combined their results into a representative composite organization, modeled the benefits and costs over three years, and risk-adjusted the financial analysis. Forrester’s TEI framework examines benefits, costs, flexibility, and risk, giving evaluators a clearer basis for judging the potential economic impact of the investment, rather than a single vendor-supplied number.
13x ROI | $47.3M NPV | Payback in under 6 months
$50.8M in three-year PV benefits vs. $3.5M in three-year PV costs
The composite organization
The modeled organization is a North American specialty retailer with 15,000 employees across 700 locations. Eighty-five percent of its workforce is hourly, annual store-level employee turnover exceeds 85%, and labor is its largest controllable expense. Before Legion, fragmented workforce management processes created inconsistent schedules, high administrative burden, and limited visibility into labor performance. The model assumes a three-month implementation, 75% workforce adoption in Year 1 and full adoption beginning in Year 2.
Where the $50.8 million in benefits comes from:
1. Scheduling optimization: $21.1 million
This is the largest single benefit in the model. Forrester modeled forecast accuracy improving from 87% before Legion to 96% by Year 2, allowing the organization to reduce both overstaffing and understaffing, tighten adherence to labor budgets, and give managers more confidence in system-generated schedules rather than manually overriding them.
“The application allows us to be nimble and dynamic. We have 21,000 stores and we can generate those schedules in about 2 hours. It used to be done once a week.”
– Senior data analyst, retail
2. Employee turnover reduction: $11 million
Retention is the benefit worth pausing on, because it’s the first time frontline turnover shows up as a hard line item in a workforce management ROI model. Forrester attributed a 10% reduction in turnover to Legion, applied against the composite organization’s 85% baseline.
Why the reduction? Greater schedule transparency, mobile access, and the ability to manage availability, time off, and shift swaps gave employees more control over their working lives, and the model captures the resulting drop in recruiting, onboarding, and training costs.
“We experienced a 21% year-over-year reduction in turnover, which is huge. At least 10% of that reduction would belong to Legion.”
– DVP of retail innovation and operations, retail
3. Manager productivity improvements: $9.1 million
Automated scheduling, simpler payroll administration, and more usable workflows freed up time that managers had been losing to routine administrative tasks. Forrester modeled seven hours saved per manager each week, with that time reallocated to customer service, coaching, training, and operational execution. The model treats this as a productivity benefit, not an assumed headcount reduction.
“The biggest win for managers is less time being in the office. Retail is won or lost on the shop floor.”
– Senior director of workforce management, retail
4. Avoided labor compliance penalties and legal exposure: $7.8 million
Built-in rules, digital attestations, and real-time validation let organizations apply complex scheduling and timekeeping requirements consistently instead of relying on manual tracking. Legion records why schedule changes occur, calculates applicable premiums, and creates an audit trail, reducing both unnecessary payouts and broader legal exposure.
“Legion dynamically assesses why it changed, and employees had to attest to it. We saw a dramatic change—90% of schedule changes were employee-initiated.”
– Senior director of workforce management, retail
5. Reduction in overtime pay: $1.6 million
Better forecasts, more proactive scheduling, and clearer visibility into overtime thresholds let the composite organization control excess hours without sacrificing coverage. Forrester modeled overtime falling from three hours per location per week, 20% of average weekly hours paid, to 0.24 hours, or 1.6%.
“We also give Legion’s schedule generation tool credit because it does a great job of basing the schedule in a way where the store has coverage while avoiding overtime when possible.”
– DVP of retail innovation and operations, retail
6. Payroll and workforce administration labor savings: $220,000
This benefit comes from a different part of the organization than the other five, corporate payroll and administration rather than the store floor. Automation and integrations removed repetitive manual work across budget uploads, user management, and payroll adjustments, freeing up time for higher-value administrative tasks.
“Just loading our budgets each week would be a 4-hour process. With the way we set up our Legion environment and the integrations we built, we were able to push it into Legion in less than 5 minutes.”
– Senior data analyst, retail
The cost side of the equation
Forrester also modeled the full cost of the investment. Three-year, risk-adjusted present value costs totaled $3.5 million: $3.2 million in Legion license fees and $346,000 for implementation, training, and ongoing management. License costs were based on a five-year agreement for the composite organization’s 15,000 employees and selected platform scope; actual pricing will vary by deployment size and modules.
Additional benefits not included in the ROI
The financial numbers don’t include several benefits surfaced in the study, either through interviews or the composite model results: a customer-reported 19% year-over-year reduction in absenteeism, stronger shift fulfillment and store coverage, rapid mobile adoption, improved workforce data visibility, faster deployment, and the employee attraction and engagement value of on-demand pay. These stood out as additional sources of value, not inputs to the 13x ROI calculation.
A framework for your own business case
The composite is a transparent, risk-adjusted model built from customer evidence and a defined set of assumptions. For evaluators, its real value is in showing where economic impact can be measured: labor alignment, retention, manager time, compliance, overtime, and administration. The next step is to test those value drivers against your own workforce, operating model, and baseline performance.
Read the full Forrester TEI study or request your own value assessment
Forrester TEI Study: 13x ROI with Legion Workforce Management | Request your own value assessment
Source note: The Total Economic Impact™ Of Legion Workforce Management, a Forrester Consulting study commissioned by Legion, 2026. Results relate to the modeled composite organization; individual results will vary.
Source: Forrester Consulting TEI study commissioned by Legion, 2026
Related Articles
Want to Hear More From Legion?
Sign up to receive the latest industry research, expert-led webinars, and practical WFM resources.